Birkbeck logo

Research
  • Subscribe
  • by RSS
  • on Facebook
  • by Twitter

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • About
  • Latest
  • Arts
    • Research leave in Venice and Padua
    • Scratching Surfaces: Attractions and Pitfalls of Using Ads as Historical Sources
    • Cultural Policies in East Asia
    • Critical Work Placements
    • Katherine Mansfield and Food
    • Picturing the Family: Media, Narrative, Memory
    • Social Media, Protest and the Arab Spring
    • A Violent World of Difference
    • Touching the Book
    • The Modernist Party
    • Günter Guillaume: East Germany’s most famous spy
    • The West Wing
  • BEI
    • Unpacking the Triple Helix: Universities, industry and government
    • Age at Work
    • Food insecurity in Palestine
    • Entrepreneurship in London’s Universities
  • Law
    • The World Prison Brief: Database of Global Imprisonment Levels
    • Judicial Images
    • Punitive Laws Undermine HIV Prevention Efforts
    • Experiences of court
    • Can Russia ever be understood?
    • Doing Development in Afghanistan
  • Science
    • Rehearsing “why” and “how” not to drink alcohol during social occasions may help promote safer student drinking
    • ExoMars landing site 2: this time it’s geological
    • Parenting by older mothers brings benefits to children
    • What the Thunder Said: Theatre-based intervention for children who have witnessed violent events
    • ExoMars Landing Site 1: Europe goes to Mars
    • A large-scale research project into early signs of autism and ADHD is long overdue
    • The emotional complexities of transplantations
    • UK-India collaboration. The way ahead for TB drug discovery
    • Alpha-1 Antitrypsin Deficiency – research update
    • Silent Witnesses: Children’s Experiences of Community Violence
    • Genes Environment Lifespan laboratory: Recent autism research
    • Research into Alpha-1 Antitrypsin Deficiency
    • Body image constructed inside the brain: Researchers measure the brain’s map of a phantom hand
  • SSHP
    • Are older people a burden? – Challenging the myths
    • Harnessing emotions in the foreign language classroom
    • Gender and Class in English Asylums, 1890-1914
    • Why “younger” is not always “better” in foreign language learning
    • ‘All they want is my money’; a relationship in crisis
    • Pardon my foreign accent!
    • Another Darkness, Another Dawn: A History of Gypsies, Roma and Travellers
    • Parents in Parliament: The Motherhood Trap
    • Responses to storm damage: early warning and evacuation planning
    • The Bay of Bengal in Global History
    • Who pays the cost of flooding?
    • Stoicism for everyday life
    • Exploring Intercultural Communication: Language in Action
    • Working elderly in India
    • Public health in post-war Germany
    • Mothers, murderers and mistresses: the empresses of ancient Rome
    • Multilingualism in psychotherapy
    • Why and how the EU’s Working Time Directive matters
    • “Most obscene title of a peer-reviewed scientific article” – an amusing award for a serious academic paper
    • Race in Vichy France
    • Au pairing after the au pair scheme: new migration rules and childcare in private homes in the UK
    • What is the point of banning discrimination on grounds of sex in insurance?
    • Obama’s Post-American Foreign Policy

Tag Archives: CMA

Posted on 10 August, 2020 by Olivia

Public Engagement Awards: Dr Walter Beckert – Constructive critique of a proposal for the Competition and Markets Authority’s approach to assess hospital mergers

Reply

This is the eighth and final blog in a series of blogs showcasing the Birkbeck 2020 Public Engagement Awards winners and highly commended participants. This project was announced as Highly Commended in the category ‘Transforming Culture and Public Life’.

In February 2019 the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) published a working paper on the impact of hospital competition on rates of patient harm in the English NHS. The Health Foundation examined the central conclusion of the CMA paper – that the research provides ‘further empirical evidence that competition ultimately benefits patients’ – finding that this cannot be substantiated from the analysis. Dr Beckert’s project outlines how more rigorous well-designed research is needed to measure the impact of competition on the quality of care.

The CMA is responsible for overseeing all proposed mergers involving NHS Foundation Trusts. The Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act (2013) also significantly altered the regulation of competition and mergers by moving it from sector-specific oversight by NHS bodies and placing it within the remit of national competition regulation law, under the control of the CMA. The CMA’s remit currently includes the review of all proposed mergers involving NHS Foundation Trusts (assessing the potential for benefits to patients relative to a potential loss of benefits arising from reduced competition) and the power to block those mergers where insufficient evidence of patient benefit has been demonstrated. To date the CMA has allowed all the NHS mergers it has considered, with one controversial exception: the proposed merger between the Poole Hospital NHS Foundation Trust and the Royal Bournemouth and Christchurch Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. The critical evaluation of the CMA’s methods to scrutinise mergers is therefore important and timely.

The main insights from Dr Beckert’s work with regard to the CMA’s approach are that it provides an underdeveloped understanding of the context in which the NHS in England operates; an underdeveloped theory of change as to how competition might lead to better outcomes; it uses suboptimal data; it uses suboptimal methods; and it draws conclusions that are unjustifiable in light of the questionable methods and data.

These insights go beyond the CMA’s present study: the CMA’s approach is shared by many similar studies by academics, economic consultancies and health market regulators. Thus Dr Beckert’s work is aimed at improving how future investigations are carried out, with a view to the empirical methodology, the data employed and the overall understanding of the healthcare sector. In doing so, the project combines the expertise of researchers in health services, health economics and competition economics, and econometrics and quantitative methods. The interdisciplinary nature of the project and the research team is a testimony to the complexity of the research task and, possibly, a blueprint for empirical research in the area of policy analysis in the future.

Birkbeck commends Dr Walter Beckert and his external partners on this critical study, which was Highly Commended in this year’s Public Engagement Awards in the Category ‘Transforming Culture and Public Life’.

Further information:

  • Birkbeck 2020 Public Engagement Award winners and highly commended candidates (video)
  • Birkbeck Public Engagement Awards
  • Research at Birkbeck
Share
. Reply . Category: Business Economics and Informatics . Tags: CMA, Competition and Markets Authority, culture, hospital, NHS, public engagement, public life

About this blog

Our academics are engaged in conducting research that is actively pushing back the boundaries of the world's knowledge across the disciplines. This blog will give you a snapshot into some of the varied research projects taking place across the College.

Latest posts

  • Exploring global disparities in criminal sentencing
  • The surprising impact of innovation on reducing climate change
  • The economics of public sector employment
  • Decision making under uncertainty: Ambiguity preferences
  • Championing a more inclusive post-pandemic digital investment landscape

Research by School

  • Arts
  • Business Economics and Informatics
  • Law
  • Science
  • Social Sciences History and Philosophy

Other blogs

  • Birkbeck Comments
  • Events
  • Library blogs
  • What would George think?

Tags

#MGMTResearch #OPResearch Applied Linguistics and Communication art Arts and culture awards birkbeck business Child development and education climate change Creative writing culture Department of Management Department of Organizational Psychology Discover our research economics economy education English and Humanities family gender government history India innovation language learning law linguistics management Mechanics’ Institute Review multilingualism planetary science Politics Politics society and law Psychological Sciences psychology public engagement Published Alumni Series research School of Arts Science and biomedicine space women work Work and the economy

Thinking about studying at Birkbeck?

Browse our course listings.

See what our students say about studying here.